Your Best Trades Already Know the Answer
You see the setup. It ticks every box. You know it's valid.
And you don't take it.
Then you watch it play out exactly how your plan said it would, and you're left sat there wondering what's wrong with you.
If that's happened to you, you're not on your own. Hesitating on trades is one of the most common things I hear about, and it happens to traders who are disciplined and profitable too. It isn't a sign you're not cut out for this.
Why picking apart the hesitation doesn't help much
The natural thing to do after you freeze is go over it again and again. Why did I do that? What's my problem? Why can't I just click the button?
The trouble is, all that does is keep you staring at the moment you got stuck. You end up with a long list of what went wrong and not much idea of what to do differently.
I'd turn that round.
Study the trades you executed well instead
Somewhere in your last month there's a trade you took without fuss. You saw it, you sized it, you clicked, and you let it play out.
It might have been a winner. It might have been a loser. That doesn't matter here. What matters is that you executed it the way you wanted to.
That trade has more to teach you about hesitation than any of the ones you froze on. It shows you what it looks like when you're already doing it right.
What to look at
Go back to that trade and look at what was around it.
Prep. What did you do before the session? Had you marked your levels? Written the plan down?
State. How did you feel when you sat down? Rested, rushed, calm, distracted?
Plan. How clear were your entry and stop before the trade showed up? Was it a decision you'd already made, or one you were making on the spot?
Space. Where were you, and what else was going on? Phone face down? Kids at school? Nothing else pulling at you?
Most traders who do this find something interesting. On the trades they took without hesitating, the decision felt made before the trade even appeared. The work was done earlier, so when the setup came, there was nothing left to argue about.
That part you can repeat on purpose.
Write it down so you can repeat it
Keep a short note each time you execute a trade well. Not your most profitable trades, your best ones. A few lines on your prep, how you felt, how clear the plan was and what your space was like.
After a few weeks you'll have your own list of what works for you. Not a rule from a book, but something you've already proven you can do.
Then on the days you feel the hesitation creeping in, you're not asking "what's wrong with me?" You're asking "which of these am I missing today?" That's a much easier question to answer.
''You don't need to become a different trader. You need to notice the one who already shows up on your good days.''
An end-of-week reset to try
Before you switch off for the weekend, give yourself five minutes with these:
→ Which trade did you execute best this week, win or lose?
→ What was different about how you went into it?
→ What's one thing from it you'll carry into Monday?
Awareness first. Perfection can wait.
Quick answers
Why do I hesitate on trades I know are valid?
Usually because the decision is still being made in the moment. If the plan isn't fully settled before the setup shows up, your mind treats every entry as a fresh risk to argue with, and freezing feels safer than clicking.
How do I stop hesitating to enter a trade?
Go back to the trades you executed well, win or lose, and note what was around them: your prep, how you felt, how clear the plan was and your space. Then set those conditions up before each session, so the decision is already made before the trade appears.
Is hesitating on trades a sign I'm not cut out for trading?
No. It happens to disciplined and profitable traders too. It's a habit around how and when you make decisions, and habits can be changed.
Should I review my losing trades or my best trades?
Both have their place, but for hesitation your best executed trades are more useful. They show you what it already looks like when you're doing it right, so you've got something to repeat rather than only a list of what went wrong.
Have a good weekend,
Alan Edward
Want more like this?
I send one short email a week on the mental side of trading and keeping it simple. No hype and no signals. Join the free newsletter here.
Two more ways I can help, whenever you're ready:
Watch the free video on how I trade in about 10 minutes a day with simple, rule-based swing trades on the daily chart.
Read The Blueprint To Trading Psychology, my short book on why you break your own rules and how to stop.
About Alan
Alan Edward (The Divergent Trader) is a full-time trader. It took him about five years to get consistent, and he now teaches a simple, low-screen-time way to trade, plus the mental side that goes with it.
Comments